the grammar being wrong also bothers me

  • CTDummy@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    8 hours ago

    He didn’t claim that? If you’re changing between PAL and NTSC formats on a digital camera it requires a reboot and formatting the memory card because they’re different formats. NTSC is 60hz base and PAL is 50hz. The difference in these frequencies need a reboot to initialise pixel and timing clocks as well as the viewfinder to match the selected format.

    Edit: also it’s internal components aren’t “conditioned” by a connected power source. What’s being stated is the other way around. These standards were originally made with the power source’s frequency in mind.

    Wiki

    NTSC is used with a frame rate of 60i or 30p whereas PAL generally uses 50i or 25p; both use a high enough frame rate to give the illusion of fluid motion. This is due to the fact that NTSC is generally used in countries with a utility frequency of 60 Hz and PAL in countries with 50 Hz, although there are many exceptions.

    • Lee@retrolemmy.com
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      7 hours ago

      The timing of the video capture is almost certainly configurable via software and can be done without rebooting as well as a number of other things related to the video format change, but I suspect the reboot is due to simplifying the software. There’s probably a lot of things done at boot time based on the video format that’s just easier to reboot than to write code that can change those values on the fly. Sure rebooting is an inconvenience to the user and it’d be better to allow it to be changed without rebooting, but probably most users don’t change video format often and requiring the reboot means they can make the software simpler (and more efficient).

      I think the bigger question is: why does changing NTSC/PAL require formatting the memory card? The frame rate of the video is independent of how the data is written to storage (aside from analog media). Even if there was a separate NTSC/PAL clock for the video capture side, the storage device doesn’t need to use the same clock and even if you did change the clock of the storage, that wouldn’t change the actual data being written, thus no need to reformat.

      The clock signal for storage writes is independent of the data being written and in fact, for all solid state media I can think of, the clock doesn’t even need to be consistent. The clock speed is effectively variable as long as other timing constraints are met (think things like max speed, but when you get in to electronics hardware, we have to get in more detail like how fast does a signal transition and how long from one signal transitioning until another is valid), but again that’s independent of the video format. It’d be like saying you can’t put a PAL and NTSC .mkv file on the same memory card or that you can’t read a memory card in a different device because they were read/written at different speeds. This absolutely can be the case with analog storage, but not solid state digital. At least none that I’m aware of.

      • CTDummy@piefed.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        6 hours ago

        I think what’s happened here is a misunderstanding that maybe weren’t helped by minor grammar missteps. Nor the reply coming in guns blazing claiming the original comment entirely bullshit.

        Like it was mentioned modern camera can change shutter speeds and exposure to account for most of what the original comment mentioned. In another comment.

        This is not even *remotely* what a high end modern camera does. Sony is obviously mum about the exact specifications of the “Bionz X” main image processor in the ɑ7RII, but it is obviously a modern highly specialized chip running most likely running at many hundreds of megahertz, completely independent of the camera’s external video output.

        If this were the case, that is the selected format having no bearing on sensor and internal clock rates (not the CPU clock); why can you find forum post with this model (or series, the MK3) where they have issues with lights flickering in captured video due to incorrect standard being selected? Which is then only fixed by selecting the relevant standard for the country? Granted I doubt they tried altering other settings.

        I think the bigger question is: why does changing NTSC/PAL require formatting the memory card?

        Yeah this I find weird as well. I agree this is likely just a simple setting that account for a multitude of things (captured video hz/fps mismatch, video output, etc). I think the problem if you set a camera you bought in a PAL region to NTSC, it’ll constantly spam you with prompts to switch on start up (which feels like a bug); leading to OPs warning. You’re not meant to flip flop between them.

        I’m not sure why it clears the file system either but I assume this is meant to be done once. Maybe Sony assumed you wouldn’t want to keep footage shot with the wrong standard (or it was sold to another person in a different region). I don’t think changing the clock rate for sensors implies also a clock change for writing to memory. Fuck knows for that aspect of it tbh.

        Edit: fixed as I thought it was a different person replying.