Today is Tuesday, 10/20 and the general US Elections are in TWO WEEKS.
As it stands right now, the current Senate composition is:
47 - Democrats
51 - Republicans
2 - Independents
Looking at the numbers, we COULD see a huge shift in the Senate this year, best case scenario would be:
52 - Democrats
45 - Republicans
3 - Independents
Chart Follows:
| State | Current | Occupant | Status | D Cand | R Cand | Polling 10/18 | Outcome | Polling Direction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colorado | Democratic | Hickenlooper | Safe D | John Hickelooper | Mark Baisley | D+6 | ||
| Delaware | Democratic | Coons | Safe D | Chris Coons | Michael Katz | D+29.7 | ||
| Georgia | Democratic | Ossoff | Safe D | Jon Ossoff | Mike Collins | D+8 | ||
| Illnois | Democratic | Durbin | Safe D | Juliana Stratton | Don Tracy | D+20 | ||
| Massachusetts | Democratic | Markey | Safe D | Ed Markey | John Deaton | D+24 | ||
| New Hampshire | Democratic | Shaheen | Safe D | Chris Pappas | John E. Sununu | D+7 | ||
| New Jersey | Democratic | Booker | Safe D | Cory Booker | Justin Murphy | D+22 | ||
| New Mexico | Democratic | Luja | Safe D | Ben Ray Luján | Larry Marker | D+18 | ||
| Oregon | Democratic | Merkley | Safe D | Jeff Merkley | David Brock Smith | D+25 | ||
| Rhode Island | Democratic | Reed | Safe D | Jack Reed | Raymond McKay | D+20 | ||
| Virginia | Democratic | Warner | Safe D | Mark Warner | Bert Mizusawa | D+20 | ||
| Minnesota | Democratic | Smith | D | Peggy Flanagan | Michele Tafoya | D+4 | ||
| North Carolina | Republican | Tillis | D | Roy Cooper | Michael Whatley | D+10 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 6/1 |
| Alabama | Republican | Tuberville | Safe R | Everett Wess | Barry Moore | R+21 | ||
| Arkansas | Republican | Cotton | Safe R | Hallie Shoffner | Tom Cotton | R+9 | ||
| Florida | Republican | Moody | Safe R | Angie Nixon | Ashley Moody | R+5.2 | ||
| Idaho | Republican | Risch | Safe R | Withdrawn | Jim Risch | R+12.1 | ||
| Kentucky | Republican | McConnell | Safe R | Charles Booker | Andy Barr | R+9 | ||
| Louisiana | Republican | Cassidy | Safe R | Jamie Davis | Julia Letlow | R+4 | ||
| Mississippi | Republican | Hyde-Smith | Safe R | Cindy Hyde-Smith | Scott Colom | R+9 | ||
| Montana | Republican | Daines | Safe R | Alani Bankhead | Kurt Alme | R+16 | ||
| Nebraska | Republican | Ricketts | Safe R | Dan Osborn (I) | Pete Ricketts | R+1 | R Momentum since 10/1 | |
| Oklahoma | Republican | Armstrong | Safe R | N’Kiyla Thomas | Kevin Hern | R+28 | ||
| South Dakota | Republican | Rounds | Safe R | Brian Bengs | Mike Rounds | R+6 | ||
| Tennessee | Republican | Hagerty | Safe R | Marquita Bradshaw | Bill Hagerty | R+25 | ||
| West Virgiia | Republican | Capito | Safe R | Rachel Fetty Anderson | Shelley Moore Capito | R+21 | ||
| Wyoming | Republican | Lummis | Safe R | James Byrd | Harriet Hageman | R+23 | ||
| South Carolina | Republican | Graham | R | Annie Andrews | Darline Graham | R+1 | R Momentum since 8/29 | |
| Alaska | Republican | Sullivan | Tossup | Mary Peltola | Dan Sullivan | D+3 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 8/4 |
| Iowa | Republican | Ernst | Tossup | Josh Turek | Ashley Hinson | D+1 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 9/10 |
| Kansas | Republican | Marshall | Tossup | Adam Hamilton | Roger Marshall | D+1 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 10/1 |
| Maine | Republican | Collins | Tossup | Troy Jackson | Susan Collins | D+2 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 7/6 |
| Michigan | Democratic | Peters | Tossup | Abdul El-Sayed | Mike Rogers | D+3 | Possible R Flip | D Momentum since 8/17 |
| Ohio | Republican | Husted | Tossup | Sherrod Brown | Jon Husted | D+4 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 6/2 |
| Texas | Republican | Cornyn | Tossup | James Talarico | Ken Paxton | D+4 | Possible D Flip | D Momentum since 6/1 |
This is giving me PTSD
I need a drink.
Voted in my tossup race yesterday; in person. This is the easy part; the cleanup we have waiting will take decades.
The fumigation alone will take decades. 😉
I’ve started using FiftyPlusOne for polling aggregation. It’s a spiritual successor to 538, but if anyone has a better option, glad to be informed:
I’ve been using Pollsmax. It’s pretty good. Of course after every election I am reminded that there will always be surprises and I need to stop treating these sites as if they were a crystal ball
Very interesting, thanks. Boy, the difference between their polling and forecast is pretty stark. They are giving huge incumbency advantages to existing GOP senate seats, for example. Polling is D53-R47, and forecast is D48-R52, a 5-seat chamber control swing.
I don’t know if that makes them more or less credible. GOP has outperformed in the past, and I’m very wary of vibes-based expectations, but Maine for example has Collins winning despite (1) their own average polling showing Jackson up by 2.7%, and three of four recent polls by 4%; (2) the last Senate seat going democratic; (3) the last presidential election going democratic; (4) the last governorship going democratic.
Makes it it feel like their forecasting formula is putting a pretty big thumb on the scale, but then again, every time I’ve allowed myself optimism in the last 10 years of elections, I’ve been disappointed.
I was hearing about a South Carolina poll today predicting that 30% of the black vote is going to Darline Graham, which just seems absurd to me…
Republicans are in panic mode over SC
Yeah, that would be something.
I think the forecasts are useful thought experiments, but it seems if you dig deep enough in the methodologies, eventually you always get to a priori premises and assumptions that can’t be supported except by intuition. It would be helpful for there to be a graphic map of those methodologies with “here be dragons” to denote when we’ve stopped using data. In any case, I’m holding onto some hope for this election despite those forecasts, but guarding it like a caveman would a fire.




